The Symphonic Juncture

A [Symphonist]: "The one who is not afraid to raise the primal force."

- Boris Asafiev (1917)

Music à la Carte: Echoes That Remain: Week 3 Review (2021)

It was 1853 and Robert Schumann had just met Johannes Brahms, and they quickly became enamoured with each other, the former calling the latter the ‘darling of the Muses, while the latter called the former his ‘Revered Master.’ However, this sacred companionship which had just been germinated was to be quickly extinguished after only four, short months. On February 27, 1854, Robert would attempt his first attack on his life, thus issuing the start of a battle unable to be reversed, culminating in the premature death of Germany’s ‘ultimate romantic only two years later [1856]. It was during this time when Brahms and Clara became inextricably close(er), and subsequently what began as a friendship became something far greater. Brahms wrote to a friend “I often have to restrain myself forcibly from just quietly putting my arms around her,” while Clara had privately written, “It is not his youth that attracts me...it is the fresh mind, the gloriously gifted nature, the noble heart, that I love in him.” Indeed, they loved with a closeted passion tantamount to Galatea’s undying devotion to her Acis, Daphnis’s commitment to his virginal Chloe, and even Tristan’s deathly devotion to Isolde, but as fate brought them together, fate would also separate them. They embarked on a voyage to Switzerland in the hopes of marriage, and instead of marriage they left with despair, Clara recounting “I feel as if I just left a funeral.


Brahms and Clara never remarried, and although they remained close, they would never love another as deeply as they had each other. Knowing their tragic development, Kallos Chamber Music Series chose to punctuate their ‘Echoes that Remain’ concert series with Brahms’s Piano Quartet No.3 [Op.60], written right in the heat of Schumann’s artistic martyrdom, made heavier with Cupid’s obstinate arrow puncturing the bosom's of the two lovers. Harnessing their natural, ensembled synergy one last time in evocative hues and memorious intonations which seek to convey the universal conflict of man, ‘what should I do,’ I was transported via the ‘recreation of life in sounding’ into the dichotomous, vacillating interiority of a Brahms caught within the grasp of merciless uncertainty. Life and death, longing and rapture, to pursue or not to pursue; via only four movements, I was introduced to Violinist Kate Arndt, the personification of Clara’s doleful status as a woman stuck within the confines of convention, Violist Jordan Bak, the voice of Robert Schumann who suffered at the hands of destiny but produced eternal beauty, and Cellist Josh Halpern, the penetrating, embodiment of Brahms and his worrisome apprehensions. With dewy gaze, I truly ‘heard’ Brahms the person and not only the composer, this process of negating the finality of silence [death] nurtured by these musicians impeccable alignment with the infinite Other for whom music is but a conduit for something far greater than material sound or baseless musical showmanship. Wrapped in the virtuosic resplendences of Pianist Min Young Kang, quite possibly the voice of our celestial Master themselves or perhaps, more accurately, the exemplification of the disquiet, Sturm und Drang undulations of a mind incapable of formulating a rational next step, only after hearing the entire work did I realize what I had was privy to and was allowed to experience.


Movement 1) I love her and shall never love another as long as I live.
Movement 2) But I am not finished living yet, I cannot give in to sorrow.
Movement 3) However I shall never forget you Robert, but my love Clara I shall never stop loving you.

concluding with...


Movement 4) So this is my fate then? To suffer a loss and then be bestowed a fierce love which drives me also to mania?

[Johannes Brahms, Piano Quartet No.3, Op.60]